Why We Need A Constitutional Convention
delivered at a press briefing in the Capitol Rotunda
We come here today in the midst of two important
anniversaries.
231 years ago this week, 56 brave souls gathered in
this Commonwealth to pledge their lives, fortunes and
sacred honor in pursuit of self-government. Our state
constitution is a direct descendant of the efforts of
those freedom fighters.
Although Pennsylvania's original constitution - in
comparison to those of other revolutionary era states -
was considered to be the epitome of self-government,
an assault on those liberties began almost
immediately. That assault reached its high water
mark, we pray, two years ago this week when
lawmakers in this Capitol twisted self-government into
an instrument of self-service.
The people - echoing the true spirit of those who
signed the Declaration of Independence twelve
generations ago - rose up, put their proverbial foot
down and said, "No More."
While things may have changed here in Harrisburg -
even to the point where some observers consider
those changes to be massive, relative to the
institutions where they've occurred - from the viewpoint
of self-government, the shift has been miniscule and
evasive at best.
Even today, we stand witness to elected officials who
refuse to adhere to the simplest portion of the ultimate
will of the people - the constitutional mandate to adopt
a fiscal plan by a fixed date on the calendar. If they
cannot abide by this very elementary provision, how on
earth can we expect them to uphold some of the more
complex mandates of our most fundamental law?
The utter failure of the legislative, executive and
judicial branches to carry out the provisions of our
Constitution are major reasons why this
Commonwealth is in desperate need of a
constitutional convention, but they are not the only
reasons.
Pennsylvanians are now realizing that a carefully
crafted convention could also go far in addressing our
broken public education system, eliminating wasteful
and overlapping local governmental fiefdoms and
repairing our inherently unfair electoral system.
There are currently two bills to initiate a convention -
HB649 and SB291 - sitting in committee waiting for
action. Both are seriously flawed and in need of major
amendment, but they are there nonetheless. Another
bill - HB1179 - calls for an appointed commission to
study constitutional change. This bill is equally flawed
in that it puts elected officials in charge of the process.
The only path back to self-government is to convene a
delegation of citizens - without ties to the current
establishment - to review and propose changes to our
Constitution and submit them to the electorate for
ratification. Anything less is simply
unacceptable.
For an acceptable starting point, we recommend
the "Citizens' Constitutional Convention Act of 2007" [now upated for 2009]
as posted at www.pacleansweep.com. Taking this
path to change would not only lead us back to self-
government, but would also remove the black cloud
which has been hanging over state government for the
last two years.
At PACleanSweep, we will be attempting to educate
elected officials of the dire need for a convention in the
coming months. Perhaps they will listen; perhaps they
won't. If they don't listen now, maybe the impetus for
action will come from their political opponents in 2008.
Only time will tell.
Elected officials who refuse to move in the direction of
a constitutional convention of the people do so at their
own peril. Article I, Section II states in no uncertain
terms that the people "have at all times an inalienable
and indefeasible right to alter, reform or abolish their
government in such manner as they may think proper."
We are not bound to do so with the consent or
agreement of any elected official, but we do think it
proper to pursue consensus at this time. If we do not
achieve consensus between the people and elected
officials, the divide between the two will only become
greater and the cloud over this building will only grow
darker.
The time is proper for a constitutional convention, and
a more opportune time may not come again for
generations.
If the 56 men who signed the Declaration of
Independence could see what has become of
Pennsylvania over the course of 231 years, they would
certainly be appalled. We owe it to them to prove that
their sacrifices were not in vain - and that we have not
lost sight of their gift of self-government - by holding a
convention of the people at the earliest possible
opportunity.
Contitutional Convention Q & A
Citizen's Constitutional Convention Act of 2009
View the text of HB649
View the text of SB291
View the text of HB1179
About PACleanSweep
PACleanSweep is a non-partisan effort dedicated to
reforming state government in Pennsylvania. For
more information, please visit
www.PACleanSweep.com.